Potato cyst nematodes (Globodera rostochiensis and G. pallida) are destructive parasites
that feed on host potato plants. Oddly enough, the potato plant itself secretes
a small molecule that stimulates the juvenile nematodes to hatch from the flask-shaped shell structure of the cyst. The parasitic nematodes then live and feed on the potatoes of the host
plant, reducing crop yields dramatically. The hatching stimulus for potato cyst nematodes is the plant natural product, solanoeclepin A (chemical
structure depicted above).
Outside the firm protective covering of
the cyst, the hatched juvenile nematodes die within a few weeks in the absence
of potatoes. One strategy for extermination of the potato cyst nematode, which
inflicts serious damage upon crop plants in numerous countries, is to spread a
dilute solution of the hatching stimulus over potato fields after the harvest.
This induces the nematodes to hatch and then die shortly thereafter due to the
lack of host plants. For this reason, solanoeclepin A is in high demand as an
investigational agrochemical that may help to address food scarcity issues of
the 21st century. For use in this type of application, a robust and
scalable chemical synthesis of a hatch-stimulating substance will be required, due to the low abundance of solanoeclepin A that is accessible from natural
sources.
The hatching stimulus for the potato
cyst nematode was first isolated in 1986 and the absolute chemical structure of
solanoeclepin A was unambiguously determined in 1999 by X-ray crystallographic
analysis. The rarely encountered structural motifs embedded within the
solanoeclepin A fused-ring skeleton pose significant challenges for synthetic
chemists. For example, the highly strained D/E/F tricyclo[5.2.1.0]decane ring system encompasses
four-, five- and six-membered carbocyclic rings. In addition, the unique
western A/B/C framework consists of an oxabicyclo[2.2.1]heptan-2-one fused to a
seven-membered C-ring. Indeed, all of the carbocyclic ring permutations from size three
(cyclopropane) to size seven (cycloheptane) can be found within the daunting architecture of solanoeclepin A. The exquisite bioactivity, scarcity in nature
and fascinating molecular structure of solanoeclepin A has made it an
attractive target for chemical synthesis. A leading reference into this body of
synthetic literature is Minoru Isobe’s recent disclosure in Organic Letters. The laboratories of
Hiemstra and Nishikawa are also actively pursuing synthetic solanoeclepin A. In
2011, Tanino and Miyashita reported the first and only total synthesis of this extraordinarily
complex, plant-derived nortriterpenoid. An overview of their tour de force
52-step chemical synthesis is provided below.
Very little is known about the
biosynthesis of solanoeclepin A. However, in order to envision a plausible
biosynthetic hypothesis for solanoeclepin A, it is instructive to first consider
the plant natural product, glycinoeclepin A. Glycinoeclepin A happens to be the
hatch-stimulating substance for the soybean cyst nematode and could potentially
serve as a relevant biosynthetic intermediate en route to solanoeclepin A. Tadashi Masamune first noted in 1985 the structural similarities between glycinoeclepin
A and cycloartane steroids such as cimigenol. Indeed, oxidative cleavage of the
cycloartenol B-ring (shown above) with loss of one carbon atom, along with
migration of two methyl groups in rings C and D leads to the pentanortriterpene, glycinoeclepin A. Additional metabolic processing and oxidative elaboration of
this seco steroid or a similar biosynthetic precursor might then culminate in
the biogenesis of solanoeclepin A. In 1994, Corey and Hong were able to "chemically emulate" the cycloartenol biosynthetic hypothesis by preparing
12-desoxyglycinoeclepin A in a semisynthetic fashion from the cycloartane
steroid abietospiran. A practical semisynthetic approach to solanoeclepin A
from a readily available plant sterol has not been investigated to date, but
would undoubtedly be of great interest to the agrochemical industry.
As noted above, solanoeclepin A was
synthesized in 52 synthetic operations from 3-methylcyclohexenone (1) by the
laboratory of Masaaki Miyashita in Tokyo, Japan. Their overall synthetic strategy was
to first assemble the eastern D/E/F substructure (e.g. 6), a trans-fused indane bearing three
contiguous quaternary asymmetric carbon centers, two of which are at the bridge
heads. This building block is then appended to a furanyl diene moiety, which is
used to construct the western A/B/C framework by means of an intramolecular Diels-Alder (IMDA)
reaction.
The synthesis is initiated by a
five-step cyclopentene annulation which is based on a conjugate addition
reaction and lipase-mediated optical resolution of the annulation product. The
details of this method were communicated back in 2006 by Tanino and Miyashita.
Stereocontrolled elaboration of the cyclopentene 2 led to the a-epoxy alcohol 3, which, upon exposure to
trimethylsilyl trifluormethanesulfonate, underwent 1,2-migration of the vinyl
group with concomitant epoxide ring-opening to furnish the hydroxyketone 4 with
excellent efficiency (97% yield). The angular vinyl moiety served as a latent
epoxide that would be utilized to forge the requisite four-membered carbocycle.
Thus, as described in the mid-1970s by Gilbert Stork, treatment of the epoxy nitrile 5
with lithium diisopropylamide induced an intramolecular cyclization reaction that
fashioned the cyclobutane portion of the highly strained eastern D/E/F bridged
substructure. A few subsequent functional group interconversion steps provided
the allylic alcohol 7 and then a stereoselective Simmons-Smith cyclopropanation, conducted in the presence of an asymmetric ligand, was utilized to install the fourth and
final carbocyclic ring of the eastern D/E/F/G polycyclic system.
From the cyclopropanation product 8,
ten additional operations were required to advance to intermediate 9, bearing a
slightly modified protecting group array along with an exocyclic methylene
projected from the cyclobutane E-ring, obtained from the selenoxide elimination
protocol of Grieco. The crucial enol triflate coupling partner 11 was later
obtained from 9 via the intermediacy of the keto enamine/vinylogous amide 10. Nucleophilic
addition to the carboxaldehyde moiety by a substituted 2-furyl lithium species
was accomplished in the presence of the neighboring enol triflate at low
temperature to afford quantitatively the a-alcohol
12, which was elaborated in two steps to intermediate 13, the immediate
precursor to the crucial IMDA substrate.
The enone system that would serve as
the eventual dienophile component in the forthcoming IMDA step was appended by means of
a palladium-catalyzed cross coupling reaction between the enol triflate 13 and
the methyl enol ether, 4-methyl-2-trimethylsilyloxy-1,3-pentadiene, to generate the adduct 14 in moderate yield. Subsequent exposure of 14 to Lewis acidic conditions
promoted an intramolecular [4+2] cycloaddition between the electron-rich
furanyl moiety and deficient enone to furnish the endo product as the predominant stereoisomer.
A two-step hydrolysis/oxidation sequence then secured the advanced trione
intermediate 16 that was eventually converted into fully synthetic
solanoeclepin A in 13 additional operations. It should be noted that 9 of the
final 13 synthetic steps entailed late-stage redox adjustments occurring at the carbon positions
denoted below in structure 16 with asterisks.
In total, 52 steps were required to
convert 3-methylcyclohexenone into solanoeclepin A in the course of the first
and only chemical synthesis of the hatching stimulus for the potato cyst
nematode. While solanoeclepin A exhibits the appropriate biological properties
for potential downstream agrochemical applications, this synthetic approach
exceeds the limits of industrial manufacturing practicality by orders of
magnitude. A realistic chemical solution that addresses food scarcity problems
related to the increasing global population and parasite-induced crop damage can
only be found in the form of structurally simplified solanoeclepin A
derivatives which retain hatch-stimulating bioactivity. Along these lines,
Corey’s laboratory has already synthesized a simplified benzenoid derivative of
glycinoeclepin A, but the detailed biological properties associated with the analogue were not
disclosed. Alternatively, and as emphasized above, a practical semisynthetic approach to
solanoeclepin A production beginning from an abundant cycloartane-type plant sterol
would be of great interest in this regard.
